What we are witnessing these days is no longer just an institutional conflict, but a grotesque spectacle in which the Superior Council of Magistracy (CSM) reveals its true face: a caste that, under the pretext of defending judicial independence, is in fact defending its material privileges and impunity.
After publicly reprimanding Prime Minister Ilie Bolojan, the CSM president, judge Elena Costache, launched a public attack on Romania’s President, Nicuşor Dan, accusing him of mismanaging magistrates’ retirement requests.
Costache went further, shouting that the Prime Minister lacks the “ability” and “authority” to initiate laws concerning judges’ pensions, invoking a version of judicial independence twisted to suit her own agenda.
But the constitutional reality is entirely different. Article 74 of the Romanian Constitution is as clear as daylight: legislative initiative belongs to the Government, MPs, Senators, and even citizens. The Prime Minister can change magistrates’ retirement conditions through a Government program of measures, and in this case, we are not even dealing with an organic law. Articles 114 and 115 explicitly allow the Government to assume responsibility for such a program, making the Prime Minister’s move perfectly constitutional. Either the CSM president does not understand the law, or she made a political statement – something that magistrates are strictly forbidden to do.
The attack on the President is equally groundless. Article 133 paragraph 6 of the Constitution states that the President of Romania presides over the meetings of the CSM when present. This is not an interference, but a clearly defined constitutional role. Accusing the head of state of violating judicial independence simply for exercising his prerogatives shows either bad faith or outright desperation.
Amidst this entire circus, no one in the CSM seems concerned that Romania risks losing €230 million from the Recovery and Resilience Plan due to the deadlock over magistrates’ pensions. Why? Because European funds are not their priority – preserving outrageous privileges obtained through institutional blackmail is.
Elena Costache shouts about independence, but the reality is this: under the cover of that word hides the protection of the corruption entrenched in Romania’s judiciary. And when the Prime Minister and President show signs of wanting to clean the system, the CSM screams as if the very essence of the rule of law were under attack. In reality, what is being defended is not judicial independence but the dependence of certain magistrates on their financial advantages and on a system that guarantees their impunity.
Elena Costache’s behavior in recent days is not that of a magistrate, but of a politician serving the interests of a frightened caste desperate to preserve its shield. Yet the law strictly forbids magistrates from engaging in political activities. If this is not sanctioned swiftly, we will remain prisoners of a judiciary that, in the name of independence, is only protecting its own corruption.




